"Loyalty program" covers very different things. Before you decide on rewards, decide which type of program fits your business. There are six to choose from.
1. Cashback and points
Members earn points or cash back with every purchase. Easy to understand and quick to start. Watch out: say clearly what a point is worth, and be aware that pure points programs can train customers to wait for discounts.
2. Tiers
Levels such as silver, gold and platinum, where higher levels unlock better privileges. Members work to reach a level and to keep it. Tiers need customer data and personal communication, and they are hard to change once levels are promised.
3. Gamification
Challenges, badges and missions. Each challenge rewards an action you want repeated, and that can be something other than a purchase, such as a review. It is harder to explain than points, so define exactly which action earns what.
4. Communities and clubs
A club around a product, a hobby or a value, with content, events and exchange between members. A club is an add-on. It needs a base program underneath and regular activity to stay alive.
5. Unconditional bonuses
Benefits every member gets without conditions: early access, an extra service, a small surprise. They create gratitude but rarely change behaviour, so they work best as an occasional extra.
6. Hybrids
Most mature programs combine types. For a first program, start with one base type and add one element for a clear purpose, such as one challenge per quarter.
Three questions before you choose
- Does it serve my objective? Purchase frequency points to a points program, basket value to tiers, win-back to bonuses and targeted offers.
- Does it fit my customers? Affluent buyers respond less to points and more to exclusivity. Busy buyers want simple rules.
- Can I run it? Tiers and communities need data, content and time. Points can run with a stamp card.
As a rule of thumb, how often customers buy and how much they spend decide the base type. Your objective decides the details.
For most first programs, the base is points.
It is the type customers already understand, and it leaves room to add a second element later.
Teach this as a course
This topic is part of the Boost Customer Loyalty trainer kit: eight modules with editable slides, exercises with sample solutions and quizzes, built around one running case.
See the eight modulesPrevious article: Why your existing customers are worth more than new ones