Small businesses spend most of their marketing money on finding new customers. The figures suggest looking at the customers they already have.
Keeping costs less than winning
Winning a new customer is five to 25 times more expensive than keeping an existing one, according to figures cited in Harvard Business Review (A. Gallo, "The Value of Keeping the Right Customers", 2014). The range is wide because industries differ. The direction is the same everywhere.
A small group carries the business
Take the example business used throughout our course, a coffee roastery with two cafes and an online shop. It is an invented case, but the pattern is typical:
- 2,400 customers, revenue of $480,000 a year
- The top 20%, which is 480 customers, bring 55% of the revenue
- The bottom half brings 15%
- A top customer spends about $550 a year, a customer in the bottom half about $60
One lost top customer equals about nine lost customers from the bottom half. Yet most small businesses could not name their top customers, and treat everyone the same.
Where a program earns its money
A loyalty program has a cost, so it has to bring extra margin. It usually comes from three places:
- Fewer blanket discounts. Rewards are earned through purchases, and no longer handed to everybody who has a code.
- Bigger baskets and more visits. Customers who are close to a reward buy more, and sooner.
- Sharper marketing. Once you know who your regulars are, you stop paying to reach people who will never return.
Do programs pay?
In the Antavo Global Customer Loyalty Report 2026, nine in ten program owners who measure the return report a positive one. The important words are "who measure it". A program without a measured objective cannot show that it pays.
Try this with your own numbers
List your customers with their revenue for the last twelve months and sort the list. Read off how much of your revenue comes from the top fifth. In the course this is an Excel exercise that takes thirty minutes, and it is often the moment when a business owner decides a program is worth the effort.
Teach this as a course
This topic is part of the Boost Customer Loyalty trainer kit: eight modules with editable slides, exercises with sample solutions and quizzes, built around one running case.
See the eight modulesPrevious article: What should your loyalty program achieve? Start with one objective